16-05-2012, 03:33 PM
Wi-Fi and Bluetooth Can Coexist in Handheld Devices
[attachment=22165]
Introduction
Imagine a room full of people talking. There may be a lot of noise, but as long as people are spread out and not conversing too loud,
two people in close proximity can successfully carry on a conversation. However, if someone nearby started shouting, it would be
very difficult to continue that discussion.
Similarly, when Wi-Fi and Bluetooth® are put into the same device—particularly a smaller handheld type—the signals transmitted can
cause interference with each other, thereby disrupting the “conversation.”
As these two wireless technologies continue to permeate the consumer electronics market, people continue to ask “Can these Wi-Fi
and Bluetooth coexist in a single device?” The answer is yes.
This white paper discusses the emergence of Wi-Fi and Bluetooth technologies on a single integrated circuit (IC) for use in today’s
popular handheld devices. It explains the potential challenges of competing wireless signals, as well as innovative design techniques
to help original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) overcome potential issues and rapidly develop cost-effective consumer devices.
Finally, it expands on the advantages that Marvell’s Avastar® family of multi-functional radios (MFRs) have over competing devices
available in the market today.
The Increasing Popularity of Wi-Fi and Bluetooth--Together
Wi-Fi and Bluetooth are two of the most widely used wireless technologies in consumer electronic devices. Although devices including
these two technologies can use separate ICs on an embedded platform, with the latest advances in technology innovation, it is
possible to co-locate Wi-Fi and Bluetooth devices on one IC, thereby reducing cost, size and time-to-market.
These technologies operate in the 2.4GHz Industrial, Scientific and Medical Device band (ISM) band, but are disparate from each
other in almost every manner. Wi-Fi devices operate on an asynchronous protocol and access the wireless medium using the Carrier
Sense Multiple Access / Collision Avoidance (CSMA/CA) mechanism. With Bluetooth devices, the medium access time is slotted. Also,
the advent of 802.11n technology in handheld platforms poses the difficult challenge to accommodate the requirements of both Wi-Fi
and Bluetooth links while ensuring optimal performance.
While it's generally acknowledged that Bluetooth and Wi-Fi can coexist in harmony, it's another matter to get them to work together
while residing in the same device. Interference problems from collisions—since both use the same radio frequency (RF) band—causes
dropped packets, which only cascades into other problems.
Despite this ambient RF interference, Bluetooth and Wi-Fi have gained increasing popularity with consumers in recent years, driven
by the array of handheld devices available today. As both technologies are placed in close physical proximity, coexistence is a
priority.
Below we outline the challenges of Wi-Fi and Bluetooth co-existence in small form-factor products, and then discuss detailed
measures that can be implemented by OEM designers to counteract any interference.
Coexistence in Handheld Devices
More and more handheld devices, from personal digital assistants (PDAs) to smartphones, are being shipped with both Wi-Fi and
Bluetooth technologies. With widespread use of these “dual-mode” devices, co-existence has become a complex challenge.
Figure 1 illustrates the most common cases for simultaneous usage of Wi-Fi and Bluetooth technologies.
[attachment=22165]
Introduction
Imagine a room full of people talking. There may be a lot of noise, but as long as people are spread out and not conversing too loud,
two people in close proximity can successfully carry on a conversation. However, if someone nearby started shouting, it would be
very difficult to continue that discussion.
Similarly, when Wi-Fi and Bluetooth® are put into the same device—particularly a smaller handheld type—the signals transmitted can
cause interference with each other, thereby disrupting the “conversation.”
As these two wireless technologies continue to permeate the consumer electronics market, people continue to ask “Can these Wi-Fi
and Bluetooth coexist in a single device?” The answer is yes.
This white paper discusses the emergence of Wi-Fi and Bluetooth technologies on a single integrated circuit (IC) for use in today’s
popular handheld devices. It explains the potential challenges of competing wireless signals, as well as innovative design techniques
to help original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) overcome potential issues and rapidly develop cost-effective consumer devices.
Finally, it expands on the advantages that Marvell’s Avastar® family of multi-functional radios (MFRs) have over competing devices
available in the market today.
The Increasing Popularity of Wi-Fi and Bluetooth--Together
Wi-Fi and Bluetooth are two of the most widely used wireless technologies in consumer electronic devices. Although devices including
these two technologies can use separate ICs on an embedded platform, with the latest advances in technology innovation, it is
possible to co-locate Wi-Fi and Bluetooth devices on one IC, thereby reducing cost, size and time-to-market.
These technologies operate in the 2.4GHz Industrial, Scientific and Medical Device band (ISM) band, but are disparate from each
other in almost every manner. Wi-Fi devices operate on an asynchronous protocol and access the wireless medium using the Carrier
Sense Multiple Access / Collision Avoidance (CSMA/CA) mechanism. With Bluetooth devices, the medium access time is slotted. Also,
the advent of 802.11n technology in handheld platforms poses the difficult challenge to accommodate the requirements of both Wi-Fi
and Bluetooth links while ensuring optimal performance.
While it's generally acknowledged that Bluetooth and Wi-Fi can coexist in harmony, it's another matter to get them to work together
while residing in the same device. Interference problems from collisions—since both use the same radio frequency (RF) band—causes
dropped packets, which only cascades into other problems.
Despite this ambient RF interference, Bluetooth and Wi-Fi have gained increasing popularity with consumers in recent years, driven
by the array of handheld devices available today. As both technologies are placed in close physical proximity, coexistence is a
priority.
Below we outline the challenges of Wi-Fi and Bluetooth co-existence in small form-factor products, and then discuss detailed
measures that can be implemented by OEM designers to counteract any interference.
Coexistence in Handheld Devices
More and more handheld devices, from personal digital assistants (PDAs) to smartphones, are being shipped with both Wi-Fi and
Bluetooth technologies. With widespread use of these “dual-mode” devices, co-existence has become a complex challenge.
Figure 1 illustrates the most common cases for simultaneous usage of Wi-Fi and Bluetooth technologies.